The Department of State Services (DSS) has urged the Court of Appeal in Abuja to dismiss appeals filed by the Socio-Economic Rights and Accountability Project (SERAP) and uphold the N100 million damages awarded against the organisation for allegedly defaming two security operatives.
The secret police made the request on Monday during proceedings before a three-member panel of the appellate court led by Justice Danlami Senchi, following arguments by parties challenging a judgment of the High Court of the Federal Capital Territory.
The appeals, marked CA/ABJ/CV/1114/2026 and CA/ABJ/CV/1105/2026, were filed separately by SERAP and its Deputy Director, Kolawole Oluwadare, seeking to overturn the N100 million damages awarded in favour of two DSS operatives, Sarah John and Gabriel Ogundele.
Represented by a legal team led by A.T. Kehinde, SAN, the DSS urged the appellate court to affirm the findings of the trial court, insisting that the judgment delivered by Justice Yusuf Halilu adequately addressed the complaints of the two operatives.
The security agency also asked the court to dismiss the appeals for lacking merit.
However, SERAP, through its counsel, Oluwatosin Adesioye, urged the appellate court to set aside the judgment and the damages awarded against it.
The organisation faulted the trial court’s findings, arguing that the two DSS operatives failed to establish credible evidence linking them personally to the publications that formed the basis of the defamation suit.
SERAP maintained that neither of the officers was identified by name, rank, designation, official position or photograph in the publications, arguing that the physical descriptions used were insufficient to establish their identities.
“The central issue in this appeal is whether the respondents established by credible evidence that the publications complained of referred to them. The publications did not name the respondents, and the descriptions relied upon were general physical descriptions which did not, without more, identify the particular individuals who brought the action,” SERAP argued in its appeal.
The organisation also challenged the trial judge’s reliance on his personal observation of the officers’ physical appearances in court to establish that they were the individuals described in the publications.
It further argued that claims of psychological distress, professional damage and reputational injury were not sufficiently supported by independent evidence.
SERAP maintained that its publications concerned the conduct of security officials who visited its Abuja office and constituted legitimate commentary on matters of public interest.
It also faulted the trial court for allegedly failing to properly consider its defence of freedom of expression, justification, qualified privilege and fair comment.
The dispute originated from publications made by SERAP on September 9, 2024, on its website and X account, alleging that DSS operatives had invaded its Abuja office and harassed a staff member.
The organisation had linked the alleged incident to its demands for President Bola Tinubu to investigate corruption allegations at the Nigerian National Petroleum Company Limited and reverse increases in petrol prices.
The two DSS operatives subsequently instituted a defamation suit against SERAP and its deputy director, claiming that the publications damaged their personal reputations and the corporate image of the security agency.
In his judgment delivered on May 5, Justice Halilu held that the publications were defamatory and awarded N100 million in damages against the defendants.
The court also directed SERAP to publish a public apology to the two operatives in two national newspapers, on two television stations and on its website.
Additionally, the defendants were ordered to pay N1 million as litigation costs, alongside 10 per cent annual interest on the judgment sum until full payment.
Following the adoption of final written addresses by the parties on Monday, the Court of Appeal reserved judgment in the two appeals to a date to be communicated to them.
The appellate court’s decision will determine whether the N100 million damages award and the accompanying orders against SERAP will stand or be overturned.









